Top Risks

• Privacy policy is Google's generic account policy — not scoped to this extension; admits data collection and 3rd-party sharing.
• Developer uses free Gmail address with no business domain; brand_mention flags YouTube impersonation.
• 4× innerHTML DOM-XSS sinks with no CSP; if API response is ever tainted, XSS possible on YouTube pages.
• No CSP declared (MV3 so no MV2 penalty, but innerHTML sinks elevate risk in absence of CSP).
• 5M-install blast radius means any future compromise or supply-chain attack has very wide reach.

Evidence

• privacy_policy_generic store Policy URL is Google account policy; scope_extension=false, data_collection=true, third_party_sharing=true → +10.0 privacy.
• brand_impersonation store brand_mention.is_impersonation=true (YouTube), confirmed_owner=false, developer_email is gmail; verified+featured cap +1.0 rep.
• verified_publisher_featured store verified_publisher=true AND is_featured_by_google=true; reputation discounts applied but capped due to policy/monetization rules.
• dom_xss_sinks crx 4 innerHTML assignments in content-script and popup with no CSP; FIX B applied: csp_present=false → +2.0 code quality.
• host_permissions_scoped manifest host_permissions limited to youtube.com and returnyoutubedislikeapi.com; function-justified, no broad <all_urls>.
• gmail_dev_no_domain store Dev email selivano.d@gmail.com; free webmail, no developer_name, no business domain; reputation floor considerations applied.
• no_bad_hosts_no_cves crx bad_host_hits=[], affiliate_hits=[], cve_findings_raw=[], monetization_hits=[]; threat intel clean.
• install_count_high store 5,000,000 installs; +1.0+1.0+0.5 webstore, minus 0.5 popularity-trust for rating>=4.0.

Permissions Breakdown

• storage low Stores extension preferences locally; no sensitive data access.
• *://*.youtube.com/* medium Host permission scoped to YouTube only; matches stated function.
• *://returnyoutubedislikeapi.com/* low Host permission to extension's own API backend; expected for function.
• content_scripts: *://www.youtube.com/*, *://m.youtube.com/*, *://youtube.com/* medium Script injected into all YouTube pages; risk scoped to YouTube only.

Pillar Scores

Scoring History

Bookkeeping